# Does AI give the same answer twice? We asked each assistant the same 300 questions three times

> Asked the same local question three times, ChatGPT kept its top pick for 83.2% of questions, Gemini for 39.6% and Claude for 39.2%. What one check tells you.

Canonical: https://www.preferly.ai/blog/does-ai-give-the-same-answer-twice
Published: 2026-11-16
Last updated: 2026-11-16

By the Preferly team

**Short answer:** it depends a lot on the assistant. We asked ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini the same 250 local questions three times each. ChatGPT gave the same top pick in all three runs for 83.2% of them. Gemini did for 39.6%, and Claude for 39.2%. So one answer from ChatGPT is a fair guide to its next one, and one answer from Claude or Gemini is closer to a single roll of the dice.

These numbers come from our study, [Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommend the same businesses?](https://www.preferly.ai/research/who-ai-recommends), which asked 300 questions, three times each, for 2,700 answers. Our [summary of the study](https://www.preferly.ai/blog/chatgpt-claude-gemini-same-300-questions) covers how the three compare with each other. This post is about each one compared with itself.

## How we measured it

Each assistant answered every question three times between November 9 and 11, 2026, with web search on and the question order reshuffled for each run. After every answer, the assistant wrote down its top pick. For each question, we checked whether the top pick was the same in all three runs.

## Same top pick in all three runs

| Assistant | Local (250 questions) | Software (50 questions) |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 208 (83.2%) | 38 (76%) |
| Gemini | 99 (39.6%) | 42 (84%) |
| Claude | 98 (39.2%) | 34 (68%) |

Two things stand out. ChatGPT is far steadier than the other two on local questions. And all three are steadier on software, where Gemini kept its top pick for 84% of questions, more often than ChatGPT did.

## The other end: a different pick every time

We also counted the local questions where the top pick was different in every one of the three runs:

- Claude: 41 of 250 (16.4%)
- Gemini: 39 of 250 (15.6%)
- ChatGPT: 1 of 250 (0.4%)

For about one local question in six, Claude and Gemini named a different business first each time we asked. ChatGPT did that once.

## What a single check tells you

A single check is a snapshot, and how much it tells you depends on who answered.

- **ChatGPT.** Over our three runs, ChatGPT put the same business first every time for 208 of 250 local questions. So one ChatGPT answer was a fair guide to the next. That's steady, but not fixed: for the other 42, the top pick changed at least once.
- **Claude and Gemini.** For about 6 in 10 local questions (151 of 250 for Gemini, 152 of 250 for Claude), the top pick changed at least once across three runs. Being named first once, or missed once, is one draw.
- **Software is steadier.** If you sell software rather than run a local business, all three repeated their top pick for most questions.

So treat one result as one data point. Ask more than once, ask more than one assistant, and note the date. That's also why the [free check](https://www.preferly.ai/start) and the reports date every result and show the exact questions asked. The free check asks 3 AI models; the [full $99 AI visibility audit](https://www.preferly.ai/ai-visibility-audit), paid once, asks 10.

## What this doesn't show

- **Whether any pick is right.** "Best" has no ground truth. A steady answer isn't a more accurate one; it's only a repeated one.
- **Why the answers change.** We measured how often the top pick held across three runs. We didn't test what makes it change.
- **Other channels.** ChatGPT was run in its app, Claude as agents with web search and Gemini through its API. A small follow-up test on 48 local questions found that the same assistant can answer differently through a different channel. That test is small and, for ChatGPT and Claude, changed two things at once: the channel, and one question per request instead of 20 per file. We didn't run the consumer Claude or Gemini apps.
- **Other places and dates.** US cities, English, three days in November 2026. The assistants change, and their answers will too.
- **Name matching** was automatic. A hand check of 120 questions disagreed with it on 6 of 360 top-pick pairs (1.7%).

_Data: Preferly, "Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommend the same businesses?" (2026), https://www.preferly.ai/research/who-ai-recommends. 2,700 answers from ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini to 300 questions, November 9 to 11, 2026. The per-question data is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with that credit._

## Questions

### If ChatGPT recommended me once, will it again?

Often, but not always. In our study ChatGPT gave the same top pick in all three runs for 83.2% of local questions. For the rest, the top pick changed at least once.

### Why does the same assistant change its answer?

This study didn't test why. It measured how often the top pick stayed the same across three runs of the same question, with the question order reshuffled each time.

### How many times should I check?

More than once, and on more than one assistant. A single answer from Claude or Gemini is one draw: for most local questions in our study, their top pick changed between runs.

## Sources

- https://www.preferly.ai/research/who-ai-recommends
