Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini agree?
Enter a business and its city. We ask ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini the same customer question once, without naming the business, and show whether their top picks agree. Free, no email.
The short answer
For local businesses, usually not. In the Who AI recommends study, ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini each gave a different top pick in 74.3% of 750 local question-runs, and all three agreed in 3.6%. The tool above asks them one question about a business like yours and shows whether their top picks match.
How to use it
- Enter the business name and its city. The website is optional; we don’t read it.
- Leave the question empty and we write one the way a customer would ask, like “best dentist in Austin”. Or type your own.
- We ask ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini that question once each, with web search on, and read the top pick from each answer.
How to read the result
All three agree: the three assistants named the same business first. Two of three agree: two named the same business, the third someone else. Three different top picks: each named a different business first.
If your business is a top pick, the result says so. The other names each assistant listed are there too, so you can see who comes up for this question.
In the Who AI recommends study, the three gave different top picks in 74.3% of 750 local question-runs, and all three agreed in 3.6%. For software questions, all three named at least one of the same products in 83.3% of 150 question-runs. Read the study.
What this does not prove
One question is one draw. The study found the assistants also change their own top pick between runs, so ask again and you may get different names. This isn’t a ranking or a score, and it isn’t the free check or the $99 report.
See what AI says about you
The free check asks 3 AI models the questions your customers ask, then shows whether they name you and where AI contradicts your website.
The full report checks 10 leading AI models and gives you every fix in order with paste-ready code, in the AI Fix Pack. $99 once, no subscription.
What this tool doesn’t cover
Whether AI names you across the questions customers ask, and where AI contradicts your website. The free check asks 3 AI models several questions and shows both.
Questions
Do ChatGPT and Claude recommend the same business?
For local businesses, mostly not. In the Who AI recommends study, ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini gave three different top picks in 74.3% of 750 local question-runs. For software they agreed far more often. Read the study
Why do the assistants give different answers?
Each one searches the web its own way and reads different sites: directories, review sites, forums and businesses’ own pages. What it finds decides who it names. Why AI recommends your competitors
Does the tool tell the assistants my business name?
Not in the question it writes: like the free check, it asks the way a new customer would, without your business name or website. If you type your own question and it names your business, we ask that question as you wrote it and say so in the result.
How is this different from the free check?
This tool asks one question, once, and shows the top picks. The free check asks 3 AI models the questions your customers ask, then shows whether they name you and where AI contradicts your website.